(Spoilers ahead, so proceed carefully.)
Elizabeth recommended Joan Bauer on her first quarter book reviews list, but I just didn't love this. I often love Young Adult books, and I really love short books (I like to feel I'm really accomplishing something and short books give me that feeling!), but the lead character felt dull at some parts and just unrealistic at others. I also kind of hate when anyone writes about a certain area in generalities or stereotypes. (Texas, in this instance, as the land of cowboy boots and Big Hair/Cars/Buildings/Whatever, which isn't a flat-out lie, but it made that part of the book feel one-dimensional.)
I loved this book so much, I got goosebumps reading it. I thought the writing was beautiful, the story unique, the love story graceful, and the true heroes of the book -- the animals -- written both magically and realistically.
I didn't love the very, very end, when the old man runs off with the circus again and not because that wasn't kind of full-circle poetic but, come on, that's illegal, right? For this circus manager to take him on the road? The liabilities!
I also didn't much care for just how damn cranky the lead character became during the chapters in the nursing home, but not because that didn't work for the story but just because he was starting to get on my nerves a little bit.
Regardless and in short: my favorite book of the year so far.
I picked up this book at BEA -- where I was last week for work -- and it was a quick and enjoyable read, overall. I hear Sarah Dessen, the author, is known for writing teenage dialogue and emotions eerily well, and I just didn't find myself agreeing with that from reading this book (the first and only book of hers I've read, though), but I also hear it's not her best.
There were also a surprising number of typos, which I don't actually mind because I work in publishing, so I get it, but it felt like it was put out in a hurry, and that left me to believe it was written in a hurry, and I think that sort of lined up with my thoughts on the plot feeling disjointed and safe at times.
I thought there was more Dessen could have done with Mclean's (lead character) relationship with her father, her parents' broken relationship, and a could-be love triangle, but none of those were explored (enough).
So, not bad, but not super satisfying either.
***
*Book Club pick